President Donald Trump promised this week to forgive all deferred payroll taxes (including those included in troops’ paychecks) if he wins re-election this fall, but lawmakers dismissed the assertion as unconstitutional and amounting to little more than pandering.
The news comes just days after federal officials confirmed that millions of federal workers — including service members from all five branches and Defense Department civilian employees — will see a pay boost of more than 6 percent for the rest of 2020, but have to pay back all of that money next year under Trump’s payroll tax deferral plan.
The move, designed to act as an economic stimulus in response to the ongoing effects of the coronavirus pandemic, has drawn criticism as a short-term ploy that could cause long-term financial damage for families whose paychecks will fluctuate over the next half year.
Many advocates have expressed concerns that troops and their families may not be able to handle significant reductions in pay for several months next year, but Trump on Thursday promised to handle that problem when it arises.
“When we win I, as your President, will totally forgive ALL deferred payroll taxes with money from the General Fund,” he said in a tweet.
“I will ALWAYS protect Seniors and your Social Security! (Democratic presidential candidate) Joe Biden will do the opposite, he will raise your taxes and DESTROY our Country!”
When we win I, as your President, will totally forgive ALL deferred payroll taxes with money from the General Fund. I will ALWAYS protect Seniors and your Social Security! Sleepy Joe Biden will do the opposite, he will raise your taxes and DESTROY our Country!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 11, 2020
Sign up for the Pay and Benefits Report
Stay up-to-date on changing military benefits and pay
By giving us your email, you are opting in to the Early Bird Brief.
The White House did not offer any explanation of how Trump might wipe away the debt, since Congress holds the power of taxation under the constitution.
In his memo outlining the payroll tax deferral, Trump instructed the Secretary of the Treasury to explore ways to eliminate the requirement to repay those taxes, to include lobbying Congress to adopt new legislation erasing the debt.
Democrats in Congress immediately attacked the president’s tax pledge.
The House of Representatives is not going to subject its staff to Donald Trump’s payroll tax scheme.
This policy will just create headaches for workers and give them smaller paychecks next year.
The Administration should let military service members and federal workers opt out. https://t.co/xTxq68CRpY
— Rep. Don Beyer (@RepDonBeyer) September 11, 2020
Rep. Don Beyer, D-Va., said that the administration “should let military service members and federal workers opt out” of the “payroll tax scheme.” Others called for the entire plan to be reversed.
The tax deferral affects all enlisted members, virtually all warrant officers and all officers up through the grade of O-4. Others who earn more than $8,666.66 a month will not have their Social Security taxes deferred and will continue to pay the payroll taxes.
Federal employees and servicemembers should not be forced into deferring their payroll taxes.
Trump’s policy will undoubtedly cause undue burden on so many individuals whose lives have already been turned upside down due to the pandemic. https://t.co/QWJPLpXiQ4
— Mark Takano (@RepMarkTakano) September 10, 2020
Repayment of the taxes would begin as early as January 1, when troops are expected to see a 3-percent pay raise go into effect. However, Congress still has not finalized plans for that annual raise, and it would not completely cover the money owed.
Reporter Karen Jowers contributed to this report.
About Leo Shane III
Leo covers Congress, Veterans Affairs and the White House for Military Times. He has covered Washington, D.C. since 2004, focusing on military personnel and veterans policies. His work has earned numerous honors, including a 2009 Polk award, a 2010 National Headliner Award, the IAVA Leadership in Journalism award and the VFW News Media award.